I have read 'Redwall' and am reading 'Mattimeo', and was was wondering if Redwall ever had a standing army or did they always just ask for volunteers once they've been attacked. So far this has resulted in a 'too little, too late' efforts and their only hope of survival seems to be based on miracles. I was just thinking with the clever individuals at Redwall they would have some sort of defense system set up.

I say we should rally togther and train a standing army. (I'll be the general of this army)

  1. Guisom
  2. Various patrols across the ages.
  3. NORT
  4. Other such things as above.

Theres never an army at redwall because redwall is a place of peace. The universe's standing army is traditionally salamandastron, though castle florent and other places maintain a guard as well.

I see, they depend on outside woodlander groups for defending the area against invaders. This is interesting since they don't really come in contact with anyone outside their walls. This probably explains how they are rarely, if ever, alerted that there's invaders in the area. Maybe since the books are written so closely within the confines of Redwall I get the sense that Redwall is the center of the universe there. Maybe it's better to think of it as just another place on the map.

then we should train an army outside of the abbey. There is plenty of land in mossflower. We could have patrols and such defending the roads making it an even safer place to live.(me still the general)

As the majority of my characters are evil… I disagree with this idea. Prepare for a smack down! jk

oh ya? Well we'll see who wins when I make my army of wolverines. Beat that tough guy  😮

I'll have an army of Kongamoto's.

I've got an army of Wookies and Fairies so I think I have the upper paw hear!!! lol

Just read the last page of Mattimeo and it says that Matthias trained the defenders of Redwall. Could this suggest an understood military presence in Redwall where the soldiers simply doubled as civilians during a time of peace yet maintaining a presence of security? While it wouldn't meet the true definition of a standing army (to me), I think it is more correct than suggesting nobody knew what an arrow looked like until being attacked.

Well, most characters in Mattimeo were in Redwall as well, so they mostly knew what weapons looked like and how to use them. Most likely they knew what they looked like before the Great War but had rarely seen any. Remember, until Cluny the Scourge, every creature in Mossflower and surrounding country knew that Redwall was a place of peace and sanctuary. That means that they must have treated vermin as well, it even hints at it in Redwall. If so they were probably relieved of weapons upon entry of Redwall, giving them an opportunity to see numerous weapons in variety. They probably didn't know how to use them until they had to fight Cluny, though. Matthias probably only trained them in basic slinging, quarterstaff fighting, hand to hand combat and maybe some archery.

it seems in most books the improvise on a make shift militia thats commanded by either the skipper or the red wall warrior or both, heck some times even log-a-log is in charge. Red wall deos have an armory and they often are good at making weapons

Redwall doesn't need a standing army! Heck, they're the good guys! They'll win whether they try to or not!

  • 13
    Posts
  • 2127
    Views